How Insurance Is Ruining Mental Health Treatment

Navigating the mess of health insurance can be a pain in the ass! Especially when it comes to mental health care. While insurance is supposed to help cover the costs of medical services, it often complicates access to quality mental health treatment. Let’s look at how insurance is undermining mental health care and what needs to change.

Access and Affordability

One of the biggest issues with insurance is the limited access to mental health services. Many insurance plans provide insufficient coverage for mental health care, making it difficult for individuals to afford the treatment they need. High co-pays, deductibles, and restrictions on the number of covered sessions are common barriers. Many insurers “carve out” benefits for mental health and substance use treatment. Meaning you could have one insurance for medical care and some obscure different policy for mental health healthcare.  These confusing hurdles discourage people from seeking help or force them to stop treatment prematurely.

 Additionally, insurance networks often have a limited number of mental health professionals. Patients may find that their preferred or nearby therapists are not covered under their insurance plan, leading to long wait times and travel distances. Though telehealth has improved barriers like transportation for many clients. Even if a therapist wants to be in network with an insurance provider, it can take weeks to months, and sometimes years to be paneled. Often therapist will be denied being paneled because “there are too many clinicians in your area.” This scarcity of in-network providers can delay or prevent timely access to care, exacerbating mental health issues.

Reimbursement Rates & Claw backs

Insurance companies often reimburse mental health professionals at significantly lower rates compared to other medical specialties. This discrepancy often deters therapists from accepting insurance or limits the number of insured patients they can afford to see. As a result, many therapists operate on a private-pay basis, further reducing access for those who cannot afford out-of-pocket costs.

 These offensively low reimbursement rates also contribute to the burnout and turnover of mental health professionals. When therapists are underpaid and overworked, the quality of care diminishes. This situation creates a vicious cycle where both providers and patients suffer.

Additionally, many clinicians fear claw backs by insurance companies. A claw back is when an insurance company demands repayment of funds that were initially paid to cover a service. This could happen because of an insurance company’s own internal error or errors in clinical documentation on the provider’s side. This could happen months to even years after services have been rendered. Many clinicians have been forced to pay pack hundreds to thousands of dollars to insurance companies. That cost is then put on the client, or the clinician never is paid for their work.  

Administrative Burden

The administrative requirements imposed by insurance companies can be overwhelming for mental health professionals. Therapists must spend considerable time on paperwork, billing, and navigating the complex requirements for insurance claims. This administrative drain takes away valuable time that could be spent on client care, improving skill set, and contributes to provider burnout.

Moreover, the process of obtaining insurance approval for treatments can be cumbersome and time-consuming. Prior authorizations and ongoing treatment reviews often delay care and disrupt the therapeutic process. Often times insurance will initially approve treatment and stop paying without notification. Leaving clients with large balances or again therapist not being paid. Clients and therapists experience frustration and stress due to these unnecessary hurdles. This is also more unpaid labor on the part of the clinician.  

Limitations on Treatment

Insurance companies often impose limitations on the types of mental health treatments they cover. Certain forms of psychotherapy may not be covered, or coverage may be restricted to a few sessions. Such as Brainspotting,  Psychedelic Assisted Therapy, and Internal Family Systems. All of these modalities have been proven to be therapeutic for clients yet do not meet the cumbersome requirements for “Evidenced Based Treatment” and the colonized system of mental health treatment. These limitations force therapists to work within constraints that may not align with the best interests of their clients.

Stigma, Misunderstanding, and Government Overreach

The way insurance companies handle mental health care reflects a broader societal stigma and misunderstanding of mental health issues. Mental health is often treated as less important than physical health, leading to disparities in coverage and care. This stigma perpetuates the notion that mental health issues are less legitimate or deserving of comprehensive treatment.

Insurance policies that inadequately cover mental health care contribute to the stigmatization of seeking help. When individuals face barriers to accessing care, it reinforces the idea that mental health is not a priority. This can deter people from seeking the support they need and perpetuate the cycle of untreated mental health issues.

In recent years with anti-trans legislation hitting almost every state in the country, it is a legitimate concern states will use insurance records to identify members of the LGBTQ community. Clinicians across the country have expressed fears of diagnosing clients with disorders like Gender Dysphoria will “out” them. Putting our clients in harm’s way. Additionally, many employers can access your mental health records through insurance leading to loss of employment or opportunities.

The Need for Change

To improve mental health care, significant changes in the insurance industry are necessary. Here are some steps that can help address the current shortcomings:

1. Parity in Coverage: Insurance companies should provide coverage for mental health care that is on par with physical health care. This includes removing limitations on the number of covered sessions and ensuring fair reimbursement rates for mental health professionals.

2. Expanding Networks: Insurance plans need to expand their networks to include more mental health providers. This will improve access to care and reduce wait times for patients seeking treatment.

3. Reducing Administrative Burden: Simplifying the administrative processes for mental health care can help reduce the burden on providers. Streamlining billing and authorization procedures will allow therapists to focus more on patient care.

4. Comprehensive Treatment Options: Insurance should cover a range of treatments, including various forms of psychotherapy and integrative approaches. Give autonomy back to clinicians and clients to decide the best course of treatment. This will ensure that patients receive the most appropriate and effective care for their needs.

5. Addressing Stigma: Insurance companies and policymakers need to work together to address the stigma surrounding mental health. Promoting mental health awareness and ensuring equitable treatment can help change societal attitudes and improve access to care.

Conclusion

Insurance is supposed to make health care more accessible, but when it comes to mental health, it often does the opposite. By recognizing and addressing the ways in which insurance policies hinder mental health care, we can work towards a system that truly supports mental well-being, the client, and therapist. It's past time for a change.

Learn about the BENEFITS of working with an Out of Network Provider.